Introduction
Following decades of economic integration with the United States driven largely by the NAFTA free trade agreement, the new Carney-lead Liberal government has identified the over reliance on the USA as a strategic weakness. Ottawa’s new strategy to diversify Canadian trade from over reliance on the United States is an ambitious one. In order to succeed, it will require an overhaul of internal trade barriers, a recalibrating of Canada’s foreign policy, and massive investment into new infrastructure links to internal and external markets.
Canada will struggle to maintain its sovereignty as long as the economy remains dependent on the international financial and trade infrastructure largely influenced by the United States. Donald Trump’s tariffs and threats of annexation merely highlight a long standing issue whereby the Canadian economy has essentially become an outgrowth of that of the United States. This can be corrected if Canada charts its own path beyond following the Washington consensus on both international diplomacy and trade. As a middle power, Canada will not be able to chart this path alone, and needs partners to build an alternative financial and trade regime to effectively de-risk. It is for this reason that BRICS is uniquely poised to address the issues Canada faces in its overreliance on the US.
Canada is currently at a disadvantage in bargaining with the US due to its overreliance. Ottawa’s lack of alternative financial and trade avenues gives immense leverage to Washington as the president knows Canada simply cannot afford to walk away from the CUSMA bargaining table without an agreement. BRICS would give Canada an alternative framework through which to conduct trade and bring in investment, giving Ottawa more cards to play in negotiations. Integration with BRICS economies would also give Canada access to cutting edge infrastructure technology vital for the growth of our domestic economy, which will in turn boost interprovincial trade, and non-US international trade which will soften dependence on the US. Additionally, the financial instruments of BRICS will help Canada access massive capital investment, helping fund new technologies and grow domestic industry.
Canada’s Vulnerable Position
A Lack of Export Oriented Infrastructure
Canada has a wealth of natural resources. Extraction of Gold, Potash, Nickel, Uranium, and rare earth minerals within Canada compete with the largest producers in the world. Canadian mines produced 200 tonnes (4th globally) of gold, 24,962 thousand tonnes (1st globally) of potash, 125,000 tonnes (4th globally) of nickel, and 24% (2nd globally) of the world’s uranium production. Canada is also one of the largest Oil and Gas producers in the world, with both the reserves and extraction technology required to capitalise on the export of the strategically vital resource.[1]
Canada’s resources are in high demand on the world stage and could be an economic boon for the economy if the competitive prices on the world market was properly utilised. However, these commodities are often sold at a deflated price to the United States due to lack of competing trade partners within Canada’s international trade landscape. Without the infrastructure to physically transport materials in large quantities to the world market via modern and reliable railways, roads, pipelines, and ports, the true earning potential of Canada’s resources is not realised.
Despite being one of the world’s largest producers of oil and gas, Canada exports almost exclusively to one market: “After meeting domestic refining needs in Western Canada, Ontario and Quebec, roughly 95% of Canadian crude oil exports are to the U.S.”[2] This is due largely to a lack of infrastructure, as the major pipelines all flow to the USA, not to ports with LNG terminals capable of bringing Canadian oil to international markets. Free trade measures like NAFTA that pressured Canadian oil refineries to shut down and move to the United States for further supply chain integration has also deepened dependence on the U.S. to refine Canadian crude. This prevents Canada from being able to choose the most lucrative buyers for exports.
Despite being the second largest country in the world, Canada currently has no high speed rail network. A large challenge in realising the export potential on Canadian resources is the large distance between reserves and the ports that would connect them to the international market. Currently, the majority of Canadian goods are transported using rail, with some sectors such as raw materials and agriculture relying on the high capacity of rail to be economically viable.[3] As a resource-centric economy, Canada depends largely on the performance of freight rail. The lack of high speed modern railway infrastructure severely limits the strength of Canadian raw material export potential.
As arctic waterways become more navigable due to climate change, transportation of Canadian goods to either the east or west coasts becomes less of an imperative for accessing the global market. As an arctic power, Canada is uniquely poised to utilize shipping lanes in the arctic to facilitate the export of goods. Despite this opportunity, Canada has only 3 major arctic ports; the Port of Churchill, and the remote Port of Iqaluit and Tuktoyaktuk Harbour, the latter two of which have little export potential. The Port of Churchill’s capacity to link Canada’s resources is also limited due to inadequate aging rail linkages that prevent it from being properly leveraged as a globally prominent export hub.[4]
Inter-Provincial Economic Links
Infrastructure projects such as high speed rail will also play a major role in the internal cohesiveness of Canada as a nation. Just as the Canadian Pacific Railways helped Canada establish itself as a nation independent from the influence of the United States, a new push for infrastructure development will increase the economic, social, and therefore political integration of the provinces within the country.
A major challenge to resisting the influence of the USA lies in the fact that each province’s ratio of trade with other provinces versus trade internationally, heavily favours international trade. Other than central Manitoba, and tiny maritime PEI and Nova Scotia, every other Canadian province has a higher volume of trade internationally than interprovincially. Since Canada’s largest trading partner is the United States, this means that most provinces trade with the US is either equal to or greater than that with other Canadian provinces. For example, Ontario’s Imports and Exports to and from other Canadian provinces sits at 42% compared to the amount it trades internationally (mostly to the USA). This means that the trade volume outside of Canada is more than double its volume with other provinces. Second place is Quebec and Alberta tied at 58%.[5]
With almost all provinces (including every major province) being more economically integrated with the United States than with fellow Canadian provinces, the national unity of Canada sits upon a weak economic foundation. A premier who governs a province that relies so heavily on trade with its southern neighbor will prioritise that relationship more than its relationship with the rest of the country. The lack of integration of Canada’s internal economy makes it significantly less self-sufficient, and therefore less resilient to pressure from the aggressive trade policy of Washington.
An infrastructure strategy that develops assets capable of cheaply transporting large amounts of cargo and people within Canada will create internal economic corridors that make the provinces more integrated, and the national economy more self-sufficient and resilient to outside threats. An east-west high speed rail network would be poised to accomplish this, but would require substantial investment and technical expertise.
Foreign Policy
Canadian foreign policy has isolated the country into dependence on the United States. Instead of using diplomacy to grow economic opportunities overseas, Ottawa’s commitment to the United States lead ‘Rules-Based International Order’ has alienated potential trading partners around the world.
When the United States imposed 100% tariffs on Chinese electric vehicles (EVs), Canada not only followed suit, but pressured Mexico to do the same. [6] This same policy regime of shutting out Chinese companies to protect American competitors extended to the tech sector, with restrictions on Chinese brands such as Huawei. Not only does this protectionism for the sake of American companies reduce internal market pressure and give the USA monopolistic access to the Canadian market – forcing Canadians to pay more for lower quality – it also prevents the possibility of non-USA companies from investing in the creation of manufacturing in Canada. Before the tariffs on Chinese EVs for example, BYD invested in a 45,000 square ft electric bus manufacturing plant in Newmarket.
The Trudeau era Liberals arresting Chinese tech giant Huawei’s CFO Weng Wanzhou at the behest of Donald Trump caused a years long diplomatic spat with the second largest economy in the world, culminating in trade restrictions and tariffs from Beijing that hurt the Canadian economy. Similarly, the Canadian immigration regime allowed large numbers of members of the Khalistan movement which India considers a terrorist element, causing a worsening of relations with the single biggest market in the world by population. This foreign policy essentially left Canada with only one large trading partner left in the United States.
The Trump administration has identified this vulnerability and exploited its leverage in its approach to Canadian-USA trade policy. The major tariffs on trade between the USA and Canada have put immense pressure on the Canadian economy. The lack of alternatives have put the Canadian government into a difficult position, and as the renegotiations for CUSMA loom, Canada’s negotiators have few cards to play.
Although some movement has been made in diversifying trade, the scale of international trade with partners other than the USA will remain limited as long as Ottawa’s foreign policy strategy is closely aligned with Washington. This is true for any country alarmed by Trump’s disregard for international trade rules and military actions against sovereign countries, especially countries such as China which have been identified by the USA as rivals. Only a foreign policy that aims to pull off a balancing act between competing powers will position Canada as truly independent – or at least more resilient to pressure – from the United States.
The Potential Role of BRICS
Insurance from USA Trade Leverage
BRICS started out as a term used to describe the largest economies outside of the G7, Brazil, Russia, India, China, and later South Africa. These countries were not heavily integrated into the USA financial system, and their economies have historically been hit with high tariffs, and even sanctions by the United States, hampering their ability to access international trade and economically develop. As a result, they would eventually go on to formalise BRICS as an institution that could be used for trade and development, giving them an avenue to sidestep the USA financial system that was repeatedly used to coerce them.
BRICS therefore offers a model for all countries around the world seeking to derisk from their overreliance on the USA, especially as the current administration in Washington has demonstrated that integration with its economy can be weaponised. Although Canada cannot fully move away from the USA due to geography and the already heavy integration of its economy with that of the United States, Canada must find ways to diversify its trade in order to maintain its independence.
By deepening ties to BRICS – an economic bloc whose sole purpose is to develop trade and investment outside the control of American coercive measures such as tariffs – Canada gives itself leverage in any negotiation with Washington. If CUSMA is Canada’s only option for accessing the trade necessary to develop, then the threat of pulling out gives Washington overwhelming leverage over Ottawa. Mark Carney’s current diversification strategy is an important first step, however bi-lateral trade agreements cannot replace the magnitude of CUSMA, and therefore is not enough to give Canada a better bargaining position. Furthermore, many of the bilateral trade agreements rely on Canada’s preferential access to the United States market through CUSMA.[7]
Infrastructure Expertise
The use of rail is integral to Canada’s ability to move raw materials and agricultural products, and the construction of cutting edge rail systems would greatly contribute to the competitiveness of Canada’s mining, agriculture, and logging industries. The BRICS nation of China is the world leader in rail technology, with its high speed rail network longer than that of the rest of the world combined. Its Maglev trains which can reach up to 600 kilometres an hour, and the new Fuxing CR400BF-GS Electric Multiple Unit (EMU) deployed in northeastern China was designed specifically for cold climates.[8] These advancements are the result of massive investment from China into rail technology, and deeper trade relations would allow Canada to benefit. China has demonstrated willingness to build massive infrastructure projects in other countries as part of its Belt and Road initiative, and any attempt to build modern rail systems in Canada to bolster our economy should include a focus on attracting Chinese expertise.
The economic impact of China’s high speed rail technology goes beyond its ability to move goods, its true economic potential is in its movement of people. For a nation the size of Canada, the fast and affordable movement of people is essential to maintaining strong business cooperation between regions, and deepening economic integration. Fast and affordable travel times help connect labour to areas in demand of expertise, and it makes the logistics of close business ties viable for corporations interested in investing in other provinces. A world bank report on the economic effects of high speed rail (HSR) found that:
“HSR greatly shortens the time between different regions, thus encouraging such interactions and improving productivity. People, logistics, and information can flow faster and more conveniently over a wider area; and there is a better allocation of resources such as talent, capital, and technology and a better match of production and consumption, thus driving economic growth.”[9]
A high speed rail network connecting all of Canada’s provinces together would have a transformational effect on the economic integration between provinces, helping Canada become a more self-reliant and cohesive national economy. HSR would therefore strengthen economic and social connection between Canadians of different regions, and serve as a nation building project reminiscent of the original coast to coast railway that provided confederation with its practical basis.
In addition to rail technology, two BRICS nations – China and Brazil – are the only countries with the cutting edge ultra-high voltage power lines, which are capable of transmitting massive amounts of power over vast distances. This technology is ideal for large countries with localised power production that struggle with voltage drop reducing productivity – such as Canada. The success of the Chinese-Brazilian joint project construction of these lines connecting the power plants in the north of Brazil to the heavily populated south more than 2000 kilometres away was the result of Brazil choosing the State Grid Corporation of China (SGCC) for the project.[10]
Mark Carney unveiled a plan to double Canada’s energy grid, an ambitious agenda which will both help provide Canada’s industrial and technology economies to rely on cheap power for a competitive advantage, and will allow Canada’s energy sector to access the entire Canadian market. In order to successfully implement this, powerlines will need to be constructed to handle this new load. The ultra high voltage lines already built in China and Brazil offer Canada a fantastic opportunity to successfully implement our energy goals, and position our economy at the forefront of energy technology.
Capital Investment Opportunities
One of the major cornerstones for trade diversification, is the capital investment from other countries into Canada. Not only does investment provide valuable funds for the expansion of domestic industry, but it also forges strong economic ties between nations that will extend into culture, business, and diplomacy. These relationships will help Canada by giving it options and respect on the international stage, without having to rely solely on the soft power of the USA.
Two middle eastern countries which export massive amounts of capital are Saudi Arabia, and the United Arab Emirates. The UAE is a member of BRICS, and Saudi Arabia is in the process of joining. Saudi Arabia has a world class sovereign wealth fund PIF, that makes it one of the premier capital exporters in the world. Meanwhile, the UAE ranks third in the world in terms of total sovereign wealth and public pension invested assets behind only the US and China, another BRICS member.[11] These investments are in a multitude of areas, including energy, mining, technology, and infrastructure.
For a country as reliant on capital from the United States as Canada is, any attempt to break away from our vulnerability to USA protectionist measure will only be as successful as our ability to attract investment from other countries. Massive amounts of funds will be required to construct the nation building infrastructure, maintain domestic manufacturing, and development of cutting-edge technologies.
If the Canadian economy were to be more accessible to capital investment from these economies, then the benefits would be immense. Canada’s sovereignty will depend on its ability to maintain domestic industry, new nation building infrastructure, and its own homegrown tech sector. Through cooperation with the economic trade avenues of BRICS, Canada would not only signal to the world that we are looking for diplomatic partnerships outside the influence of the United States, but would also gain access to the financial channels that include some of the biggest capital exporting economies of the world.
Another avenue for capital investment through BRICS is the New Development Bank. This financial lending institution was created due in part to the alienation of the BRICS countries from the financial systems of the United States led ‘Rules-Based International Order’. This alienation is evident when BRICS was still early in its formation, in the joint statement by BRICS leaders at the Durban summit in 2014 which argued that “neither global capital markets nor the existing collection of multilateral development banks have been up to the task of mobilizing the necessary recourses for infrastructure projects – in the BRICS economies or across the developing world”.[12] This sentiment has only evolved over time, in parallel with the multipolarity movement among countries outside of the G7. The New Development Bank has the potential to pose a serious challenge to existing global financial systems led by the United States.
One of the attractive aspects of the BRICS and the New Development Bank is that it offers countries another option instead of relying on investment through international financial systems that could be weaponised using sanctions and tariffs from the United States, or its allies. The BRICS countries are building the New Development bank as a way to finance major infrastructure projects, driving development while simultaneously ensuring strategic financial resilience. A closer relationship with BRICS may offer the New Development Bank as an option for capital investment into Canada through financial mechanisms that cannot be weaponised by Washington as a pressure tactic.
Conclusion
Canada faces many challenges in both the utilisation of its current resources, and its ability to grow its domestic economy. A lack of infrastructure required to move resources and products to high demand markets, a domestic industrial base overly dependent on one trade partner, poor economic integration between provinces, and isolated diplomatic standing all culminate in an existential threat for the Canadian economy. These weaknesses were exploited by Washington in CUSMA negotiations, and have been highlighted by the Liberal Government as a problem to be addressed in part through trade diversification.
However, trade diversification needs a broader strategy of engagement with an international economic framework which can serve as a real alternative to the financial and trade institutions dominated by the United States. BRICS countries have already identified this fact and have been building trade networks, financial institutions, and diplomatic relations that allow members and associate members to effectively insure resilience from sanctions, tariffs, and any other hostile economic coercive measures from Washington.
If Canada were to position itself as a more neutral actor on the world stage by associating closer with BRICS, and chart a policy regime more independent from the United States on both international relations and international trade, then it would give the government access to financial institutions and state partners outside the influence of the United States. This in turn would give Canada the financial and diplomatic base through which to assert its independence from the USA and successfully diversify trade and assert economic sovereignty.
References:
- Government of Canada. “Mining Data, Statistics and analysis” June 25th, 2025. https://natural-resources.canada.ca/minerals-mining/mining-data-statistics-analysis/minerals-metals-facts/gold-facts
- “Canadian Exports of Crude Oil and Natural Gas.” Canadian Association of Petroleum Producers, October 2025, 8. https://www.capp.ca/wp-content/uploads/2025/11/Canadian-Exports-of-Crude-Oil-and-Natural-Gas-October-17-2025.pdf.
- Theriault, Megan. “Transport Canada: 8 Industry Myths Debunked: Expert Zoom.” Transport Canada: 8 Industry Myths Debunked | Expert Zoom, March 30, 2026. https://expert-zoom.com/ca/magazine/general/transport.
- Rutgers, Julia-Simone. “Big Dreams – and Risks – at the Port of Churchill.” The Narwal, February 27, 2026. https://thenarwhal.ca/port-of-churchill-pipeline-plans/.
- Government of Canada, Statistics Canada. Interprovincial and international trade flows, basic prices, summary level, November 6, 2025. https://www150.statcan.gc.ca/t1/tbl1/en/tv.action?pid=1210008801.
- Benchetrit, Jenna. “Why Politicians and Industry Groups Are Calling Mexico a ‘back Door’ for Chinese EV Automakers | CBC News.” CBCnews, November 20, 2024. https://www.cbc.ca/news/business/mexico-china-ev-automakers-1.7386314#:~:text=Politicians%20and%20auto%20industry%20groups%20in%20the%20U.S.,to%20circumvent%20North%20American%20tariffs%20on%20its%20products.
- Mukherjee, Promit. “Mark Carney’s Trade Push Collides with Reality of US Dependence | Reuters.” Reuters, June 9, 2026. https://www.reuters.com/business/mark-carneys-trade-push-collides-with-reality-us-dependence-2026-06-09/.
- Xinhua. “China’s Self-Developed Technology Advances Its High-Speed Railways.” Global Times, December 14, 2025. https://www.globaltimes.cn/page/202512/1350494.shtml.
- Lawrence, Martha B.; Bullock, Richard G.; Liu, Ziming. “China’s High-Speed Rail Development (English)”. International Development in Focus Washington, D.C. : World Bank Group. June 6th, 2019 http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/933411559841476316
- Xin, Zheng. “China’s State Grid Breaks Ground on Major Brazil Power Project.” Chinadaily, June 26, 2026. https://global.chinadaily.com.cn/a/202606/26/WS6a3e16fba310986e2b46214c.html.
- Amir, Khitam Al. “UAE Ranks Third Globally in Sovereign Wealth Assets, Right behind Us, China.” Gulf News, July 3, 2025. https://gulfnews.com/business/economy/uae-ranks-third-globally-in-sovereign-wealth-assets-right-behind-us-china-1.500186230?
- Chin, Gregory. “The BRICS-led Development Bank: Purpose and Politics beyond the G20” Global Policy Volume 5, Issue 3 p.367. York University. September 2014.
[1] Natural Resources Canada
[2] Canadian Exports of Crude Oil and Natural Gas. (2025). Canadian Association of Petroleum Producers, 8.
[3] Theriault, Megan. “Transport Canada: 8 Industry Myths Debunked: Expert Zoom.” Transport Canada: 8 Industry Myths Debunked | Expert Zoom, March 30, 2026.
[4] Rutgers, Julia-Simone. “Big Dreams – and Risks – at the Port of Churchill.” The Narwal, February 27, 2026.
[5] Government of Canada, Statistics Canada. Interprovincial and international trade flows, basic prices, summary level, November 6, 2025.
[6] Benchetrit, Jenna. “Why Politicians and Industry Groups Are Calling Mexico a ‘back Door’ for Chinese EV Automakers | CBC News.” CBCnews, November 20, 2024.
[7] Mukherjee, Promit. “Mark Carney’s Trade Push Collides with Reality of US Dependence | Reuters.” Reuters, June 9, 2026.
[8] Xinhua. “China’s Self-Developed Technology Advances Its High-Speed Railways.” Global Times, December 14, 2025.
[9] Lawrence, Martha B.; Bullock, Richard G.; Liu, Ziming. “China’s High-Speed Rail Development (English)”. International Development in Focus Washington, D.C. : World Bank Group. June 6th, 2019
[10] Xin, Zheng. “China’s State Grid Breaks Ground on Major Brazil Power Project.” Chinadaily, June 26, 2026.
[11] Gulf News. “UAE ranks third globally in sovereign wealth assets, right behind US, China.
[12] Chin, Gregory. “The BRICS-led Development Bank: Purpose and Politics beyond the G20” Global Policy Volume 5, Issue 3 p.367. York University. September 2014.

